bullet  Home  bullet  Weather  bullet  World  bullet  Tropical cyclones  bullet  Forecast verification  bullet

Tropical cyclone activity and forecasts - March 2007

1. Tropical cyclone activity

1.1 Tropical cyclones ending during the month

  NWP NEP NAT NI SWI AUS Total
Total number ending during the month 0 0 0 0 2 5 7
 
Name Identifier Basin Start date End date 1-minute MSW 10-minute MSW
Gamede 15S SWI 21 February 02 March 105 95
Odette - AUS 02 March 06 March - 45
George 17S AUS 03 March 09 March 110 105
Jacob 18S AUS 07 March 12 March 75 75
Indlala 19S SWI 12 March 06 March 115 95
Kara 20S AUS 25 March 28 March 80 85
Becky 21P AUS 26 March 29 March 70 60

Basin name abbreviations:
NWP : North-west Pacific (west of 180° E)
NEP : North-east Pacific (east of 180° E)
NAT : North Atlantic
NI : North Indian (west of Malay Peninsula)
SWI: South-west Indian (west of 90° E)
AUS: Australian (east of 90° E)

1-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 1 minute (JTWC Hawaii, NHC Miami, CPHC Hawaii)
10-minute MSW: Maximum sustained wind (knots) averaged over 10 minutes (JMA Japan, Southern Hemisphere RSMCs and TCWCs)
Note: Although 1-minute average winds should be stronger than 10-minute average, this may not be the case here since estimates are obtained from different warning centres.

1.2 Tropical cyclones still active at the end of the month

Name Identifier Basin Start date
Jaya 22S SWI 30 March
Kong-rey 01W NWP 31 March

2. Forecast error statistics

The Met Office global Numerical Weather Prediction model produces a 6-day forecast every 12 hours. The performance of the model in forecasting this month's tropical cyclones is assessed below. Mean error statistics for each storm that ended during the month are presented together with a final table of statistics for all storms ending this month. Verification is performed at 24 hour intervals up to forecast time T+120. Some mean error statistics for last year's storms are included for the purposes of a comparison. The present global model has a resolution of 0.5625°x 0.375°x 50 levels. This is equivalent to a horizontal resolution of 62km x 42km at the equator.

The Met Office verification scheme identifies the centre of a tropical cyclone in the model by locating a local maximum of relative vorticity at 850hPa. This local maximum is also used in the verification of intensity. A fourth order interpolation is used to locate the centre accurately. Advisory data received in real time from various tropical cyclone warning centres are used as verifying observations of storm location.

The terms used in the statistics tables are explained below:

Possibly verified  Number of forecasts fulfilling requirements 1, 2 and 4 below.
Detection Rate Percentage of possibly verified forecasts which also fulfil requirement 3 below.
Mean DX Mean of positional errors in the East-West direction.
Mean DY Mean of positional errors in the North-South direction.
Mean AT Mean of positional errors in the Along Track direction.
Mean CT Mean of positional errors in the Cross Track direction.
Track skill Percentage skill of model forecast position against CLIPER.
Mean DPE Mean of direct positional errors.
Intensity skill Percentage skill of model in predicting strengthening or weakening (positive if better than chance).


All errors are measured in kilometres except where indicated.

  1. Observed maximum wind at least 31 knots at the verifying time.
  2. Forecast tropical cyclone centre equatorwards of 45 degrees.
  3. Forecast tropical cyclone centre relative vorticity above a critical limit for verification (1.0x10-4 per second).
  4. Observation within 6 hours of verifying time present for use in verification.

Track skill is defined as:- (CLIPER DPE - Model DPE) / CLIPER DPE x 100%

Positive skill indicates the model forecast is better than CLIPER.
Negative skill indicates the CLIPER forecast is better than the model.

A diagrammatic explanation of other error statistics and their sign conventions can be found in Appendix A. Full details of the TC verification scheme can be found in nwp Gazette, Vol.1, No.2, December 1994.

2.1 Individual tropical cyclone summaries

Name: GAMEDE Identifier: 15S
Basin: SOUTH-WEST INDIAN
Start date:  21.02.2007 End date: 02.03.2007
1-minute MSW: 105 knots 10-minute MSW:  95 knots

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 18 16 14 12 10 8
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX -3 -73 -189 -191 -125 164
Mean DY 11 34 -126 -279 -477 -653
Mean AT 19 53 -12 -155 -366 -607
Mean CT 3 7 -115 -192 -375 -151
Track skill (%) **** 27 18 15 **** ****
Mean DPE 50 130 305 452 599 771
2005-6 DPE * 62 149 202 353 554 697
Intensity skill (%) **** -38 -14 33 -40 50

* DPE for all storms in the 2005-6 season in the SWI basin

Link to plot Plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts

Track forecast errors were above last season’s average for this storm at lead times of T+48 and greater. The model indicated a slow down in motion mid-way through the storm’s life as actually happened, but tended to push Gamede too far west into Madagascar. Despite the large track errors, skill scores against CLIPER were positive.

 

Name:ODETTE Identifier: -
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (Coral Sea)
Start date: 02.03.2007 End date: 06.03.2007
1-minute MSW: - knots 10-minute MSW: 45 knots

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 3 1 0 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 **** **** **** ****
Mean DX 0 214 **** **** **** ****
Mean DY 4 -22 **** **** **** ****
Mean AT -1 107 **** **** **** ****
Mean CT 6 -192 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 25 220 **** **** **** ****
2005-6 DPE * 69 136 252 391 561 495
Intensity skill (%) **** -100 **** **** **** ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2005-6 season in the AUS basin

Link to plot Plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts

Odette was a short-lived storm and only one forecast was verified.

Name:GEORGE Identifier: 12P
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (South-east Indian)
Start date: 03.03.2007 End date: 09.03.2007
1-minute MSW: 110 knots 10-minute MSW: 105 knots

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 13 11 9 7 5 3
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 100
Mean DX 15 -155 -544 -855 -1254 -1487
Mean DY -18 23 -76 -161 -276 -341
Mean AT 3 85 56 -34 -461 -691
Mean CT -12 -99 -399 -646 -1023 -1153
Track skill (%) **** -25 -87 -150 **** ****
Mean DPE 63 174 566 886 1287 1533
2005-6 DPE * 69 136 252 391 561 495
Intensity skill (%) **** 64 78 43 20 33

* DPE for all storms in the 2005-6 season in the AUS basin

 

Link to plot Plot of the depression's observed track and forecasts

The Met Office global model shared the same error as several other numerical models and failed to predict the sharp leftwards turn and landfall of George. This led to huge track forecast errors and negative skill scores. The error seems to be associated with the model’s failure to predict the formation of TC Jacob and its interaction with George.

Name:JACOB Identifier: 18S
Basin: AUSTRALIAN (SE Indian)
Start date: 07.03.2007 End date: 12.03.2007
1-minute MSW:75 knots 10-minute MSW: 75 knots

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 11 9 7 5 3 1
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 80 67 0
Mean DX -9 -40 -47 11 -364 ****
Mean DY -14 -23 -54 86 301 ****
Mean AT -10 -82 -84 35 -233 ****
Mean CT 0 -44 25 -47 -369 ****
Track skill (%) **** 58 80 89 **** ****
Mean DPE 60 149 123 131 498 ****
2005-6 DPE * 69 136 252 391 561 495
Intensity skill (%) **** -11 -14 -50 100 ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2005-6 season in the AUS basin

 

Link to plot Plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts

The model did not predict the formation of Jacob well and dissipated the storm in some of its early forecasts too soon. However, of the forecasts verified track errors were generally low and skill scores high.

 

Name:INDLALA Identifier: 19S
Basin: SOUTH-WEST INDIAN
Start date: 12.03.2007 End date: 16.03.2007
1-minute MSW: 115 knots 10-minute MSW: 95 knots

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 9 7 5 3 1 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 100 100 ****
Mean DX -9 -55 17 175 438 ****
Mean DY -16 17 15 15 -89 ****
Mean AT 8 49 3 -138 -387 ****
Mean CT -12 0 25 85 222 ****
Track skill (%) **** -37 -54 -159 **** ****
Mean DPE 46 88 105 195 447 ****
2005-6 DPE * 62 149 202 353 554 697
Intensity skill (%) **** 100 60 -33 -100 ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2005-6 season in the SWI basin

 

Link to plot Plot of the depression's observed track and forecasts

Track forecasts for this storm were low. However, due to exceptionally small CLIPER errors, skill scores were negative.

 

Name:KARA Identifier: 20S
Basin:AUSTRALIAN (SE Indian)
Start date: 25.03.2007 End date: 28.03.2007
1-minute MSW: 80 knots 10-minute MSW: 85 knots

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 5 3 1 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 **** **** ****
Mean DX -6 -21 -137 **** **** ****
Mean DY -2 41 -89 **** **** ****
Mean AT 12 -26 -151 **** **** ****
Mean CT 11 -37 64 **** **** ****
Track skill (%) **** 64 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 40 97 165 **** **** ****
2005-6 DPE * 69 136 252 391 561 495
Intensity skill (%) **** 100 100 **** **** ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2005-6 season in the AUS basin

 

Link to plot Plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts

Kara was fairly short-lived, but the turn of the storm towards the coast was well predicted.

Name:BECKY Identifier: 21P
Basin:AUSTRALIAN (SW Pacific)
Start date: 26.03.2007 End date: 29.03.2007
1-minute MSW: 70 knots 10-minute MSW: 60 knots

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 5 3 1 0 0 0
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 **** **** ****
Mean DX -40 0 21 **** **** ****
Mean DY -11 38 33 **** **** ****
Mean AT -14 35 34 **** **** ****
Mean CT -28 -9 5 **** **** ****
Track skill (%) **** 75 **** **** **** ****
Mean DPE 76 72 35 **** **** ****
2005-6 DPE * 69 136 252 391 561 495
Intensity skill (%) **** 100 -100 **** **** ****

* DPE for all storms in the 2005-6 season in the AUS basin

 

Link to plot Plot of the storm's observed track and forecasts

Becky was relatively short-lived, but track forecast errors were low and the T+24 skill score high.

 

2.2 Summary of all tropical cyclones

Mean error statistics for all tropical cyclones (of at least tropical storm strength) which have ended this month are shown below.

Total number of depressions ending this month: 7
Number of storms used in statistics below:7

MEAN ERROR STATISTICS
  T+0 T+24 T+48 T+72 T+96 T+120
Possibly Verified 64 50 37 27 19 12
Detection Rate (%) 100 100 100 96 95 92
Mean DX -4 -69 -214 -296 -434 -287
Mean DY -6 18 -76 -157 -313 -568
Mean AT 5 30 -10 -91 -379 -630
Mean CT -4 -34 -130 -260 -521 -424
Track skill (%) **** 29 12 5 **** ****
Mean DPE 54 133 296 490 770 979
2005 DPE * 67 140 237 379 559 571
Intensity skill (%) **** 24 19 15 -11 45

* DPE for all southern hemisphere storms in 2005-06 season

Comments:
This month’s statistics are dominated by TCs Gamede and George and show large track forecast errors at lead times greater than T+24. There was a modest amount of skill over CLIPER and there was a right-of-track bias in forecasts. The overall intensity tendency skill score was 18%..